What is Bail? A Historical and Modern Perspective
Constitutional Basis
​
Bail is a legal mechanism guaranteed by the Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, which prohibits excessive bail, excessive fines, and cruel and unusual punishment. The primary purpose of bail is to ensure that a criminal defendant will appear for trial and any pre-trial hearings for which they are required to be present.
​
Historical Background
​
The concept of bail can be traced back to as early as 400 A.D. in Anglo-Saxon England. In this ancient legal system, a defendant would need to find a friend or family member willing to serve as a "surety." The surety would then be obligated to pay a predetermined settlement in the event that the defendant failed to appear in court. This historical practice laid the groundwork for modern bail systems, creating an incentive structure that encourages defendants to face justice.
​
Secured Bail: Victim-Focused and Justice-Centered
​
In today's context, "secured bail" refers to a system where a set amount of money or property is pledged to the court as a guarantee that the defendant will appear for trial. If the defendant fails to do so, the bail amount is forfeited, and the defendant may be apprehended.
Secured bail is often described as "victim-focused and justice-centered" because it:
-
Holds Defendants Accountable: By attaching a financial or material incentive to their court appearance, defendants are less likely to evade justice, thereby respecting the rights of victims.
-
Protects Public Resources: Since the bail is often paid by the defendant or their surety, the cost burden is not placed on taxpayers, freeing up public resources for other uses.
-
Reduces Jail Overcrowding: By enabling pre-trial release, secured bail can alleviate the burden on jails and detention centers, which are often overcrowded and underfunded.
​
Modern Variations
​
Over the years, the bail system has evolved to include various forms, such as:
-
Cash Bail: The defendant or someone on their behalf pays the full bail amount in cash. This amount is returned if the defendant appears at all required proceedings.
-
Surety Bond: A bail agent agrees to take responsibility for the defendant's appearance in court, charging a fee for this service.
-
Property Bond: Real estate or other substantial property is used as collateral to secure the defendant's appearance in court.
-
Release on Own Recognizance (ROR): For minor offenses or low-risk defendants, the judge may allow release without any financial assurance, based solely on the defendant's promise to return.
-
Unsecured Bond: A bond that holds the defendant financially responsible only if they fail to appear in court.
​
Conclusion
​
Bail serves as a critical junction in the criminal justice system, balancing the defendant's right to freedom before trial with the public's interest in ensuring that justice is served. Rooted in centuries-old practices and continually adapted to modern needs, bail remains an enduring and essential component of the American legal system.